Caseflicks

Michigan Supreme Court • 1926

Dinsmore v. National Hardwood Co.

208 N.W. 701 | 234 Mich. 436 | 1926 Mich. LEXIS 596

Full access

Unlock the video and quiz

The written brief is free to read below. Subscribe to watch the video explainer and take the quiz.

Create an account Log in

Takeaway

In short, this case holds that false regulatory filings do not create a private fraud claim for an investor who neither received nor relied on them in making the investment.

Background

Dinsmore sued National Hardwood Company, a Delaware corporation, claiming that the company fraudulently sold him securities. His declaration rested exclusively on alleged material misrepresentations the company made to the Michigan securities commission before the commission authorized the company to offer its stocks and bonds for sale in Michigan.

At the time, Michigan’s securities statute required a foreign corporation seeking to sell securities in the state to file financial information, a prospectus, and advertising materials with the commission. The records were public, and false statements made to deceive the commission were criminally punishable. Dinsmore did not allege that he had seen, known of, or relied on the company’s filings before buying; he reviewed them only long afterward.

The circuit judge dismissed the declaration, concluding that statements and proceedings before the securities commission did not state a cause of action against the company under the circumstances alleged. The Michigan Supreme Court reviewed whether that dismissal was correct.

Issues

Issue #1

Whether a purchaser may maintain an action for fraud and deceit based solely on false representations a corporation made to the Michigan securities commission, when the purchaser neither knew of nor relied on those representations when purchasing securities.

Holding

No. Statements made to the securities commission to obtain permission to sell securities do not support a purchaser’s fraud action unless they were intended to influence the purchaser and actually did so.

Reasoning

The securities-law filing requirement served a regulatory purpose. A foreign corporation submitted financial information and related materials so that the commission could decide whether to permit securities sales in Michigan. The application was directed to the commission, not issued as an inducement for members of the public to purchase the securities.

The statute itself rejected any suggestion that the commission’s authorization guaranteed the quality or safety of the securities. Each certificate was required to state prominently: “The commission does not recommend the purchase of this security.” Although knowingly deceiving the commission was a misdemeanor, that criminal prohibition did not transform regulatory filings into representations made to prospective investors.

A fraud-and-deceit claim requires a sufficiently direct relationship between the false statement and the person claiming injury. Ordinarily, the representation must be made to that person, to the public or a class that includes that person, or with an intent to influence that person’s conduct. A statement made only to a government regulator for the purpose of obtaining a license or approval is too remote from a later investor’s decision to purchase.

Dinsmore did not claim that he knew about or relied on the company’s disclosures to the commission when he bought the securities. The commission’s public records were available for his inspection, but he did not examine them until long after his purchase. Because the alleged misrepresentations neither reached him nor influenced his purchase, they could not establish actionable fraud against him.

The court found support in decisions holding that false statements in regulatory certificates or prospectuses create liability only for persons whom the statements were addressed or intended to influence. Like the purchasers in those cases, Dinsmore could not recover merely because the company obtained permission to conduct business or sell securities through allegedly false statements to a public official.